The AP and Sarah Lawrence College have both recently issued statements about gender-sensitive pronouns.
Earlier this month, Sarah Lawrence College updated its editorial style guide to include gender-neutral language, including “humankind” in lieu of “mankind,” “chair” in lieu of “chairman,” and “they” as a singular pronoun, in lieu of “he or she.”
The latter change is considered grammatically incorrect by some, but the school seems to believe the change is worthwhile. Daniel Trujillo, dean of studies and student life, explained in a statement issued to The Huffington Post:
He emphasized that this practice ― which is outlined in the school’s editorial style guide ― pertains to internal usage and is directed at students. Still, the school’s choice is part of a wave of changes being made among institutions responsible for distributing information.
At the end of 2015, The Washington Post announced that is now allows employees to use the singular “they” to refer to genderqueer individuals. The publication still preferred that a sentence be recast as plural when possible, so singular pronoun quagmire could be avoided altogether.
And, just last week, The Associated Press issued a similar update to its style guide, writing that subjects who don’t identify as either male or female should be referred to by name, or else as “they/them/their,” if re-wording the sentence isn’t possible.
The Chicago Manual of Style has its own guidelines for avoiding exclusive pronoun use, too, including restating the noun the pronoun is meant to replace, and revising the clause altogether. While the 16th edition of the stylebook prefers ‘he or she’ as a last resort, a recent update to the 17th edition is more explicitly accepting of the singular ‘they.’
Not everyone is on board with the changes, for reasons both thoughtful and pedantic. Last year Amanda Hess argued in The New York Times, “It’s precisely the vagueness of ‘they’ that makes it a not-so-ideal pronoun replacement. It can obscure a clear gender identification with a blurred one.” It’s difficult, then, for genderqueer individuals to assert their identity, when the aligning pronoun is oftentimes used in other contexts as a mistake. Less considered arguments, such as Gersh Kuntzman’s at New York Daily News, call the change “tyranny by the uneducated, lazy or merely millennial,” and seem merely progress-averse.
But is the singular “they” really so revolutionary? A professor of English and Linguistics at the University of Illinois, Dennis Baron, compiled a history of singular, genderless pronouns, beginning in the late 1700s. In March of 1794, a writer for The Medley or New Bedford Marine Journal defended the use of a singular “they,” writing, “we wished to conceal the gender.”
Shortly after, in 1808, Samuel Taylor Coleridge wondered in his notebooks, “Whether we may not, nay, ought not, to use a neutral pronoun relative, or representative, to the word ‘Person’ [...]”.
The timeline continues, citing regular criticisms of English’s lack of gender-inclusive language. In 1845, abolitionists said the use of “he” to refer to all people impeded women’s success; in 1868, the alternatives “en,” “han” and “un” were suggested by various publications. Defenses of the singular “they” surfaced in local newspapers, and was defended by Ursula K. Le Guin, whose science-fiction stories explore gender fluidity.
If she, and Coleridge, and a bevy of other writers from centuries past, could embrace the pronoun, isn’t it time the rest of us do, too?
Clarification: Language has been added and amended regarding the Chicago Manual of Style, to reflect that it does not establish firm rules as much as offer guidance on usage and that a recent update of the manual does allow for more latitude in the use of a singular “they.”
- Witches Explain How To Take On Political Power With Occult Magic
- This Broadway Play Is What Art Should Look Like In Trump's America
- My Ex Became A Totally Different Person After Our Divorce
- The Wild History Of One Of Our Most Popular Fonts
- Shoshanna, Forever The Best 'Girls' Character, Has Evolved To A Higher Plane
- 97 Ways Of Saying The Same Hateful Thing: 'Get Out Of America'
- Maud Lewis 'a very Canadian story,' says Maudie director
- As the freshman Supreme Court justice, Neil Gorsuch will have 'cafeteria duty' and a few other hazing rituals
- Rex Tillerson just gave Russia an ultimatum
- Paris gets Hadid-mania, as Saab and Mugler channel dark, 80s
- Booker T. Jones, on the Stax Records soul sound he helped create
- Literary treasures from Corpus Christi College at Oxford arrive in Washington
You might also like
- I’m Taking A Break From Social Activism And OMG I Need Like Everyone I Know To Read About This
- My Ex Became A Totally Different Person After Our Divorce
- The Public Should Pay Only For Public Schools, Not Religious Schools
- For Public Schools, It's Been '1984' For Quite A While
- 5 'Fate Of The Furious' Moments So Unnecessary, They're Necessary
- The Androgynous 'Third Gender' Of 17th-Century Japan
- Trump's Pick To Lead The Army Believes Being Transgender Is A Disease
- Senate Confirms Neil Gorsuch To Supreme Court After Historic Blockade Of Obama's Nominee
- Jeff Sessions Prepares DOJ For Crackdown On Unauthorized Border-Crossers
- Family Immigrant Detention Centers Struggle To Get Child Care Licenses
- Trump Administration Won't Routinely Separate Families At The Border After All
- New Sheriff Closes Joe Arpaio’s Infamous ‘Tent City’ Jail
- Powerful South Carolina political consultant implicated in indictments of a veteran state senator
- Will Donald Trump get a second Supreme Court nomination?
- "Hazing" rituals await Supreme Court's "junior justice" Neil Gorsuch
- The hunt is on for Planet Nine. Here's how to join it
- Trump approves controversial Keystone XL oil pipeline
- Trump praises 'Fox & Friends,' renews old feuds in early morning tweets
- Rex Tillerson finally answers question from NBC News' Andrea Mitchell
- First Read's Morning Clips: The Latest in the Russia Investigation
- Spicer: 'I've let the president down'
- Russian President Vladimir Putin met with U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson on Wednesday
- OMB Diriector Mick Mulvaney: Washington's 'a lot more broken' than Trump thought
- Trump attacks conservatives over failure of health care bill
- A very consequential week didn't go well for President Trump
- Health Care Showdown: Republicans look to go big or go home
- No deal on health care bill after conservatives meet with Trump
- CA gov on those supporting health bill: 'Their name is going to be mud'
- Give it to me straight, doc: Is Obamacare dying?
- First Read's Morning Clips: Waiting for CBO
- 14 People Share What's It's Really Like to Have An Ex Who Is Now Their In-Law
- The Internet Is Freaking Out About The Way This Chef Cuts Pizza
- Calendar: Highlights from around town
- Tribute at Alex Theatre to honor the Band
- The Radical Power Of Lana Del Rey's Smile
- Inside One Female Photographer's Mission To Normalize The Nude Male Body
- New 'Serial' Podcast, 'S-Town,' Just Debuted All Its Episodes At Once
- 'Books Not Bombs' Initiative Promotes Education For Syrian Scholars
- How One Grandma's Modest Closet Found Its Way Into The Met
- In 1981, Margaret Atwood Made A Stirring Case For Investing In Culture
- White Artist's Painting Of Emmett Till Sparks Protest, Controversy And A Viral Hoax
- Despite Death Threats, Nazi-Themed Trump Billboard Artist Plans More
- Relive Your College Years With This Thoughtful, Hilarious Novel
- Some Theories On Trump's Bizarre Misuse Of Quotation Marks
- Gorgeous Portraits Capture Sisterhood Among Muslim American Teenagers
- Hundreds Of Stuffed Animals At The Jewish Museum Pay Unlikely Tribute To Immigrants
- Here's How You Can Help Fight Street Harassment With Public Art
- Artist Paints Interracial Couples Just Being, Together
- Jane Austen Has Become An Alt-Right Icon, Somehow
- Photographer Chronicles The Glamorous Hairstyles Of West Africa's Beauty Salons
- 23 Recent Books By Women You Should Read ASAP
- Arts Advocates Denounce Proposed Elimination Of The NEA And NEH