The definition of consent, and what it means to be able to give it, has been a subject of nationwide discussion following a Nova Scotia judge's comments in acquitting a Halifax taxi driver of sexual assault.
The recent acquittal of a Halifax taxi driver accused of sexual assault has sparked debate about consent and how the law handles it.
In his ruling, Judge Gregory Lenehan said the prosecution had not offered any evidence the woman, who was found unconscious in the car by a police officer, had not consented. He has also drawn fire for his comment that "clearly, a drunk can consent."
Nova Scotia's Public Prosecution Service has appealed the acquittal, citing grounds related to the issue of consent.
The definition of consent, what it means to be able to give it and how alcohol factors into the law, has been a subject of nationwide discussion. Here's a closer look at what the law actually says:What the Criminal Code says about consent
Consent is defined in the Criminal Code as "voluntary agreement of the complainant to engage in the sexual activity in question."
Janine Benedet, a law professor at the University of British Columbia's Peter A. Allard School of Law, puts it this way:
"The question is whether the person in their own mind wanted this sexual activity to take place."
According to the code, no consent is obtained when the agreement comes from someone other than the complainant, the person is incapable of consenting or is induced by the accused abusing a position of trust, power or authority.
Consent also does not exist if someone "expresses, by words or conduct, a lack of agreement to engage in the activity" or if the complainant, who previously consented, expresses "a lack of agreement to continue to engage in the activity."What the Supreme Court of Canada has said
According to the decision R v. JA, consent to sexual activity is only possible if the person is conscious during that activity.
In that decision, the court wrote that "when the complainant loses consciousness, she loses the ability to either oppose or consent to the sexual activity that occurs.
"Finding that such a person is consenting would effectively negate the right of the complainant to change her mind at any point in the sexual encounter."What it means to be 'incapable' of consenting
The code says there is no consent where someone is incapable of consenting.
Various factors affect an individual's capacity to voluntarily agree to sexual activity, according to Canadian law. One factor courts sometimes consider is whether the accused was in a position of authority, said Benedet.
"There are provisions in the Criminal Code that talk about consent being vitiated when someone is in a position of trust or authority," she said.
Despite the idea of a position of trust impairing the ability for there to be consent, Benedet said there continues to be debate in the case law about "what kind of relationship really puts you in a position of authority."What about intoxication and consent?
Intoxication is also considered a factor that affects a complainant's capacity to consent to sexual activity.
But in practice, Benedet said, the threshold of intoxication at which point someone is deemed incapable of consent varies depending on the circumstances.
Where a complainant becomes intoxicated involuntarily, for instance, by being drugged, "courts [tend] to be very generous in terms of what level of intoxication would be sufficient to amount to incapacity."
If a complainant consumes drugs or alcohol by choice, courts have "a very high threshold for incapacity, much higher than they would have applied in those involuntary intoxication cases."'Clearly, a drunk can consent'
While Lenehan's comment has sparked outrage in much of the public, he's not incorrect according to Canadian case law.
"You can find many criminal decisions that use the line 'a drunken consent is still a consent,' and I do think … Canadian law is reluctant, and in my view too reluctant, to find that intoxication can vitiate consent," said Benedet.
- Mohamed Salim, charged in string of N.L. home invasions, linked to Dixon City Bloods
- Inquest ordered into Yukon First Nations woman's death
- Auditor general finds gaps in Nunavut's health-care training and recruitment
- SPOT device use down, rescues due to vehicle breakdowns up in Nunavut
- Major labour contracts remain unsigned as Nova Scotia budget looms
- Battle over access to Sherbrooke Lake almost over
- First black female Mountie pushes for more diversity in senior positions
- Want to influence the government? Many lobbyists don't know how, says Graham Steele
- Ottawa approves next stage of LRT, wants to speed up link to Gatineau
- 'Incredibly violent': Woman describes unreleased video of fatal arrest
- 'Milestone' reached in Phoenix fix, public servants assured
- Const. Daniel Montsion's no-show at bail hearing a 'head-scratcher,' lawyers say
You might also like
- 'Holy Mackinaw!' Leafs broadcaster Joe Bowen reaches 3,000 games behind the mic
- Leafs get back on winning track against Red Wings
- 3 mumps cases confirmed at 3 different schools, says Toronto Public Health
- 911 call reveals man won't let women hired as dancers leave Atlanta mansion
- "The Good Fight" doesn't shy away from Trump on TV
- WikiLeaks posts trove of CIA documents detailing mass hacking
- GOP scores wins as it advances health bill to replace Obamacare
- Republican plan to replace Obamacare slammed by conservatives
- Democratic lawmaker aims to block border wall funding with taxpayer dollars
- Mike Pence says Turkey ties are "affirmation" of decision to fire Michael Flynn
- Fight for endangered vaquita porpoise gets violent in Mexico
- Assange says WikiLeaks to help tech firms thwart CIA hacking
- Powerful South Carolina political consultant implicated in indictments of a veteran state senator
- Will Donald Trump get a second Supreme Court nomination?
- "Hazing" rituals await Supreme Court's "junior justice" Neil Gorsuch
- The hunt is on for Planet Nine. Here's how to join it
- Trump approves controversial Keystone XL oil pipeline
- Trump praises 'Fox & Friends,' renews old feuds in early morning tweets
- Rex Tillerson finally answers question from NBC News' Andrea Mitchell
- First Read's Morning Clips: The Latest in the Russia Investigation
- Spicer: 'I've let the president down'
- Russian President Vladimir Putin met with U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson on Wednesday
- OMB Diriector Mick Mulvaney: Washington's 'a lot more broken' than Trump thought
- Trump attacks conservatives over failure of health care bill
- A very consequential week didn't go well for President Trump
- Health Care Showdown: Republicans look to go big or go home
- No deal on health care bill after conservatives meet with Trump
- CA gov on those supporting health bill: 'Their name is going to be mud'
- Give it to me straight, doc: Is Obamacare dying?
- First Read's Morning Clips: Waiting for CBO
- 14 People Share What's It's Really Like to Have An Ex Who Is Now Their In-Law
- The Internet Is Freaking Out About The Way This Chef Cuts Pizza
- Malala Yousafzai becomes honorary Canadian
- Text of Malala Yousafzai's speech Wednesday to a joint session of Parliament
- Controversy over video comparing abortion to Holocaust shown in Catholic high school
- Foul play not suspected in deaths of four people found in burning N.B. house
- Plans to bring high-speed internet to remote First Nations with 3,600 km cable
- Deadly wrong-way collision kills four in Quebec
- Gov. Gen. David Johnston reflects on Vimy and horrors of war
- Canadian accused in Yahoo hack denied bail, judge criticizes parents
- Attention, Gardiner commuters: You've got one more week to use the York-Bay-Yonge off-ramp
- Alleged hitman in brazen Toronto shooting sent message about 'contract killing,' Crown says
- After 6 suspected overdoses, Toronto councillors want amnesty for users who test drugs
- How do you fix child care in Toronto? Get all 3 governments to spend billions on it, report says
- Review of York Region District School Board finds 'culture of fear,' 'systemic discrimination'
- Peel school board steps up meeting security 'to ensure people are safe'
- 'The feather and the Bible were together': A tragedy is helping to mend a city's racial divide
- 5 things we learned about the changing nature of news from The National in Conversation
- 'We hear you': Sudbury city official says cyclists, pedestrians will have a voice at city hall
- Any cuts made to Saskatoon's budget may be permanent, city manager warns
- Council approves demolition of low-rental housing for college residence
- 'It's just not a strong signal': Residents in rural P.E.I. asked to test their internet speed