An L.A. County Superior Court judge said that the Oscar-winning director's fugitive status disqualifies him.
A Los Angeles County judge has denied the latest effort by Roman Polanski to resolve his 40-year-old statutory rape case, saying that the filmmaker cannot be sentenced in absentia because he remains a fugitive from justice.
In a written decision handed down Monday, L.A. County Superior Court Judge Scott Gordon said that Polanski’s current motions are based on the same arguments previously presented and rejected by other judges. “No sufficient or compelling basis for reconsideration of these issues … has been presented,” he wrote in the 13-page decision.
Gordon wrote that Polanski’s fugitive status prevents him “from obtaining the relief he desires until he presents himself in the court’s jurisdiction.” The ruling is similar in substance to previous court decisions in which judges have said that Polanski, who fled the United States in 1978 and resides in France, must return to the country in order to pursue his requests.
But on Monday, Gordon agreed to a hearing later this month to consider a controversial piece of testimony that the filmmaker is seeking to unseal.
In recent court filings and at a court hearing in March, Polanski asked to be sentenced in absentia, arguing that he has already exceeded the custody time he was originally required to serve. He also noted that courts in Poland and Switzerland have turned down separate extradition requests by U.S. officials, citing procedural irregularities in the case.
The 83-year-old filmmaker has offered to return to the United States and appear in court if it agrees to sentence him first.
Harland Braun, Polanski’s defense attorney, said in an interview Monday that the decision is “a total whitewash and abdication of judicial responsibility.” He said the decision fails to address crucial elements of the case, including allegations that prior judges were told by court officials how to rule.
“I represent an attempt to straighten out 40 years of judicial misconduct and to see if L.A. Superior Court can heal itself. It can't,” Braun said.
When asked if Polanski plans to continue pursuing the case, Braun said: “We're going to decide what to do.”
For years, Polanski has alleged extensive judicial misconduct, starting with the original judge. The filmmaker contends that the corruption has continued for decades, arguing that subsequent judges followed marching orders set by court officials.
The director has long sought to unseal testimony given in 2010 by Roger Gunson, the original prosecutor in the case. Polanski’s lawyer has argued that the testimony contains vital information and should be part of the public record.
At the March hearing, the filmmaker’s attorney withdrew his request to unseal the documents but reinstated the request days later, asking the court to “lift this unnecessary veil of secrecy.”
The court said Monday that a hearing regarding the Gunson testimony has been set for April 26.
The decision marks the latest chapter in a complex legal battle that began when Polanski was arrested at a Beverly Hills hotel in 1977 on suspicion of having sex with a 13-year-old girl he had photographed for a magazine assignment. He later pleaded guilty to unlawful sex with a minor.
L.A. County Superior Court Judge Laurence Rittenband sent the director to a Chino prison for a 90-day diagnostic study. Polanski was released after 42 days on the recommendation of the prison.
What happened next has been the subject of contention between Polanski, the court and the district attorney.
Polanski has argued that Rittenband promised that his stay in Chino would constitute the entirety of his time in custody. But he contends the judge, facing intense media scrutiny, reneged on the promise. Fearing additional prison time of indeterminate length, Polanski left the country.
The highly sensationalized case was one of the most-followed legal dramas of the era. Polanski was already a highly acclaimed filmmaker at the time, having directed movies such as “Rosemary’s Baby” and “Chinatown.”
The slaying of his pregnant wife, Sharon Tate, a decade earlier by members of the Manson family only added to the public’s fascination.
A deal was almost reached in 1997 for Polanski to return to the United States and be sentenced to time served. But the director backed out at the last minute upon learning that the court proceedings would be televised.
In 2008, the documentary “Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired” reignited public interest in the case with new interviews alleging judicial misconduct on the part of Rittenband.
The following year, Polanski was arrested in Switzerland while on his way to a film festival in Zurich. After spending several months in prison and under house arrest, Polanski was freed by Swiss officials who declined the United States’ extradition request.
A similar request failed in Poland in 2015, with a judge citing alleged unethical behavior by Rittenband.
Braun, Polanski’s attorney, argued at the March hearing that the filmmaker has served more time than he was originally promised when counting the time spent in custody in Switzerland.
But prosecutors argued that Polanski’s fugitive status disqualifies him from seeking any resolution. Deputy Dist. Atty. Michele Hanisee called Polanski a celebrity who “wants special treatment.”
The new ruling echoes past court decisions in the case in which judges have invoked the fugitive disentitlement doctrine to bar Polanski from resolving the case from the safety of his home in Europe. Since fleeing the United States, Polanski, who holds dual French-Polish citizenship, has resided primarily in Paris.
In 2009, a California appeals court judge said that the lower court could sentence Polanski in absentia and urged an investigation into the allegations of judicial misconduct in the case. But Polanski’s lawyer contends that the recommendation was ignored by the lower court.
Samantha Geimer — the victim who was 13 years old when the crime took place — has in recent years voiced her support for the dismissal of the case against Polanski.
The L.A. County district attorney’s office declined to comment.
Polanski has continued to make movies in Europe. He won an Oscar in 2003 for directing the Holocaust drama “The Pianist,” but didn’t return to the United States to accept the award.
He is in post-production for his latest movie, “Based on a True Story,” which stars his wife, the French actress Emmanuelle Seigner.
This article was originally published at 3:50 p.m.
Copyright © 2017, Los Angeles Times
- Roman Polanski's rape victim Samantha Geimer speaks out: 'He's apologized, I forgive him'
- Architect and community visionary Joe Wai dead at 76
- NYC's Chinatown Finally Represented By An Asian-American In State Assembly
- Poland's top court refuses to extradite filmmaker Roman Polanski
- Roman Polanski extradition request rejected by Poland's top court
- Poland's top court upholds refusal to extradite Polanski
- Roman Polanski extradition: Polish court refuses to send director to U.S.
- What should the future of Vancouver's Chinatown look like?
- Exploring Chinatown: 5 things you may not know about Vancouver's historic district
- Woman who scammed Chinese immigrants with 'blessings' nabbed
- Chinatown arch renovation highlights need for a makeover
- Acclaimed Polish director Andrzej Wajda dead at 90
You might also like
- Essential Politics: Paddling in the swamp to get things done
- Why I waited two hours for an elusive 'Beauty and the Beast' cup
- Fox News pulls Judge Napolitano over his Trump wiretap claims
- I swiped right and got a life coach, not a life partner
- After deadly bombings, Egypt's state of emergency reassures some but strikes fear in others
- Egypt plunged into state of emergency as Palm Sunday church bombings kill at least 44
- Gorsuch's impact on divided Supreme Court will begin immediately
- In a surprise move, Iran's Mahmoud Ahmadinejad files to run for president
- Essential Politics: To Russia, with (no signs of) love
- G-7 nations call for diplomacy after rejecting new sanctions against Russia
- U.N. warns of famine in Africa and western Asia as it seeks billions of dollars to prevent catastrophes
- Dan Stevens channels his beastly side in 'Beauty and the Beast' prologue dance
- Powerful South Carolina political consultant implicated in indictments of a veteran state senator
- Will Donald Trump get a second Supreme Court nomination?
- "Hazing" rituals await Supreme Court's "junior justice" Neil Gorsuch
- The hunt is on for Planet Nine. Here's how to join it
- Trump approves controversial Keystone XL oil pipeline
- Trump praises 'Fox & Friends,' renews old feuds in early morning tweets
- Rex Tillerson finally answers question from NBC News' Andrea Mitchell
- First Read's Morning Clips: The Latest in the Russia Investigation
- Spicer: 'I've let the president down'
- Russian President Vladimir Putin met with U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson on Wednesday
- OMB Diriector Mick Mulvaney: Washington's 'a lot more broken' than Trump thought
- Trump attacks conservatives over failure of health care bill
- A very consequential week didn't go well for President Trump
- Health Care Showdown: Republicans look to go big or go home
- No deal on health care bill after conservatives meet with Trump
- CA gov on those supporting health bill: 'Their name is going to be mud'
- Give it to me straight, doc: Is Obamacare dying?
- First Read's Morning Clips: Waiting for CBO
- 14 People Share What's It's Really Like to Have An Ex Who Is Now Their In-Law
- The Internet Is Freaking Out About The Way This Chef Cuts Pizza
- Angels manager Mike Scioscia rethinks the use of his closer in tight games
- Chemistry onstage makes Faith Hill and Tim McGraw a top tour
- I’m Taking A Break From Social Activism And OMG I Need Like Everyone I Know To Read About This
- 5 'Fate Of The Furious' Moments So Unnecessary, They're Necessary
- Noah Cyrus Reveals Her Next Tattoo & Dishes On Her Famous Family
- The Lonely Island Tell The Story Of How 'Dear Sister' Came To 'SNL'
- 'Marketplace' is America's most popular business show. Now it has ambitious plans to expand
- United fiasco shows airlines' power over passengers — and how it might change
- 'I really did it for my daughters': L.A. radio host Wendy Walsh on why she spoke out against Bill O'Reilly
- Trump backs Fox News host Bill O'Reilly, but advertisers keep fleeing
- IFC swings for the comedy fences with Funny or Die's 'Brockmire'
- MGM to spend $1 billion for full control of the Epix movie service
- YouTube TV launches today. It has some cool features and some big drawbacks
- 'Boss Baby' to sack 'Smurfs,' and other box office predictions
- Meet the new faces aboard 'Mystery Science Theater 3000's' Satellite of Love
- Werner Herzog wouldn't live anyplace other than Los Angeles, 'the city with the most substance'
- 'A blemish on America': The arts world reacts to proposed cuts in Trump's budget
- Brian Grazer and Ron Howard's Imagine Entertainment is getting into the booming, competitive animation business
- Fox News faces another sexual harassment claim as Mercedes and Hyundai pull ads from 'O'Reilly Factor'
- Settlements of more sexual harassment claims against Bill O'Reilly are reported